|
Most people
who own a television (read here: you) are probably pretty
familiar with the Saturn product – a cute, reliable commuter
car targeted at single buyers who like to have a free donut
while their car is in for an oil change. You probably also
know that these same Saturn owners are invited to Retailer
picnics, new owner clinics, and get birthday cards for their
cars in the mail. However, if you are shopping for a
performance car, you are more likely concerned with "what’s
under the hood?" or "what are the skidpad numbers?" This
article is intended to answer those questions, with a bit of
humor thrown in to break up the monologue. If you are going to
spend 10 minutes of your time reading this article you may as
well laugh a little! To put it
another way, we have been invited to share a few of our Saturn
Club Racing experiences with the readers of GRM, but in the
process we hope to generate some interest in one of the
best-kept secrets in racing – the Saturn SC2.
So, Why
Would Anyone Want To Race A Saturn?
This is a
question my wonderful wife wrestles with daily, but when you
look at the recent successes of Saturn racing efforts…
- 1997 - SCCA Solo II
E-Stock National Championship
- 1997 - SCCA World
Challenge Manufacturer’s Championship
- 1998 - Two SCCA Showroom
Stock C Runoffs top-15 finishers (that’s us!)
- 1998 - LeMans GT1
Category Champions (ok, so I made that last one up)
…one has to
think that these cars have some basic competition potential,
and by the end of this article you will understand just what
the Saturn competitive advantages are. If you do not, then
we should stick to racing and can the journalism.
Of course,
the next question that comes to mind is, "why is it then
that there are so few Saturns competing?" One theory is that
since Saturn is the ‘new kid on the block’, the word simply
is not out yet (possibly). Another reason could be the
relative lack of aftermarket support and information
available (probably). And finally, a contingency program
sure would help, Saturn (bingo).
Saturn
Competition Classifications - SCCA Solo II
In general,
all unmodified 2-series Saturns (look for a catchy sidebar
somewhere around here to tell you what ‘2-series’ means) are
classified in SCCA’s Solo II E-Stock, and modified 2-series
Saturns compete in C Street Prepared. Unmodified 1-series
Saturns are classified in H-Stock, and modified 1-series
Saturns compete in D Street Prepared. (Since we Club Race,
we do not track yearly changes in Solo II classifications,
so be sure to grab a Solo II rulebook before you try to
argue this point with the event Chair.)
There have
been a whole bunch of E-Stock Saturns showing up for the
Solo II Nationals each year, and many more competing around
the country in local events. Show up to your local club’s
event, and chances are pretty good that there will be a
Saturn or two running through (or over) the pylons.
Saturn
Competition Classifications - SCCA Club Racing
The
1997-1999 SC2 and SL2 (see another useful sidebar elsewhere
in this article to decode that cryptic string of letters and
numbers) are classified in the SCCA’s Showroom Stock C
category. As far as we know, there are 2 SSC cars in the
entire country. Remember the contingency comment above…?
The earlier
1991-1994 SC2’s only are classified for competition
in Improved Touring A, but there are not a lot of Saturns
showing up at the ARRC. To the best of our knowledge, there
is 1 ITA Saturn running around the northeast US.
Which
Models Should Be Considered By The Street / Autocross
Enthusiast?
Out of the
box, both the Saturn SC2 and SL2 are the clear-cut choice
for the sporting daily driver or for the occasional
autocross competitor. Both cars combine the rev-happy 16
valve engine with 4-wheel independent suspension, front and
rear anti-sway bars, 15 inch wheels, and low curb weight to
make for an agile performance package. Although the SW2
combines these same elements, the lack of rear strut tower
bracing and the additional 65 pounds ‘way up high’ do not
make for the best combination. In addition, while the
1-series siblings might seem attractive due to their lower
curb weight and H-Stock classification, the smaller front
anti-sway bar (and the lack of a rear anti-sway bar) does
not do much for the handling, and the torque-heavy SOHC
engine is better suited to running to the grocery store.
Which
Models Should Be Considered By The Road Racing Enthusiast?
If Club
Racing in SSC is your ultimate goal, the subtle differences
between the SC2 and the SL2 become more important. We
selected the 1997 SC2 for the following reasons:
- Lower coefficient of drag
(0.310 for the SC2 vs. 0.318 for the SL2)
- Higher top speed limiter
(124 mph for the SC2, 108 mph for the SL2)
- Lower curb weight (SCCA
limits the SC2 to 2375 lb., the SL2 to 2385 lb.)
- Shorter tire diameter (SCCA
limits the SC2 to 205/50R15, the SL2 to 205/55R15)
In ITA, you
don’t have much of a choice - you are required to run a
1991-1994 SC2, period. These early SC2’s do have some slight
advantages over their newer SC2 counterparts, though:
- Shorter wheelbase (99.2"
for 1991-1996 vs. 102.4" for 1997-1999)
- Lower curb weight (weight
savings of about 100 lb.)
So, for the
sake of discussion, let’s say that you have decided to
purchase a 1997 Saturn SC2. Good choice! We will now walk
you through – from our experience – what modifications the
Saturn really likes, what to stay away from, and where to
get the parts and information you need to build your car for
street / autocross use and road racing competition.
How Do I
Prepare A Competition Saturn?
When the
time comes to prepare your Saturn for either
high-performance street or competition use, you will learn
very quickly that there are not a lot of knowledgeable
Saturn aftermarket tuners. The one glaring exception is SPS
– The Saturn Performance Specialists. While several
companies sell a few Saturn bolt-on pieces here and there,
SPS takes the time necessary to develop and test all of
their products before offering them for sale. Most of the
products we will be mentioning are available from their
catalog, or through their website at www.spswebpage.com.
(Yes, they are a sponsor. How did you guess?)
In addition,
you should be forewarned that working on a Saturn can be a
very ego-boosting experience. Since the cars were designed
from a clean sheet of paper, a high priority in the original
design was serviceability. Nearly everything on the car
comes apart with a handful of sockets, wrenches, and a
flathead screwdriver. If you ever go back to owning any
other vehicle after working on a Saturn, you will realize
how spoiled Saturn owners are. I have a friend with an F500,
so I get a good dose of this several times every race season
– trying to troubleshoot his cooling system last year was
like trying to replace the wing of a 747…while it was in
flight!
Time To
Trade In Those Magnetic Numbers!
All Saturns
employ a steel spaceframe covered by polymer body panels
(sort of like a tube frame race car, but without all the
tubes). In fact, the only metallic body panels on the car
are the hood, roof, and rear decklid. As testimony to the
polymer panel durability, our 1997 SSC car has experienced
two full seasons of on- and off-track excursions. With the
notable exception of a rear quarter panel where a Neon front
wheel machined its way completely through the
plastic, the panels look as good as new (he made the pass,
too). Examine any other Showroom Stock car after similar
exposure, and you will be reaching for the body hammers –
the Neon was…
In addition
to providing great durability, the spaceframe / polymer
construction helps to drastically lower the vehicle weight.
Most Saturns weigh less than 2400 lb. – even with all of the
power accessories and creature comforts added in. Our SC2
tipped the scales at a lean 2288 lb. right off the assembly
line, and the final race car, complete with cage and full
interior, weighs only 2390 lb.
Wheel And Tire
Selection
Regardless
of the car you drive, wheel and tire purchases separate the
proverbial ‘men from the boys’. Without the proper wheel and
tire combination, all the money you spend on your trick
suspension parts and aggressive brakes will be wasted. I
know this is trite, but it is where ‘the rubber meets the
road’ (no more bad puns, I promise).
Weighing in
at a hefty 16 lb., the stock SC2 Aluminum wheels are neither
the most attractive nor lightest wheels you can fit in the
Saturn fenderwell. They are sized as follows:
|
Diameter |
Width |
Offset |
Bolt
Circle |
|
15 inches |
6.0
inches |
50mm |
4 x 100mm |
For
competition use, we do not recommend upsizing the
wheel diameter. It looks great on the street, but the larger
16 inch or 17 inch wheel increases both rotating mass and
rolling radius, negatively impacting gear ratio – and the
Saturn needs plenty of gear. If legal, you should find the
lightest 15" x 6.5" or 15" x 7" wheel you can afford. If you
buy from a reputable source, they will make sure the offset
is correct for your application, but be sure to ask since
there is not much clearance between the Saturn wheel and the
rear strut – especially if you run aggressive camber angles!
Tire size is
dictated primarily by wheel width and strut clearance. From
the stock 195/60R15, the first step is to change to a
205/55R15. This size works well for most high-performance
street applications, and is the size we use on our SL2
project car. For competition use, however, the sidewall is
too tall and flexible.
For road
racing and autocrossing alike, the tire size of choice is
the 205/50R15. There are multiple advantages to running this
size tire:
- This size is commonly
available in ‘R’ compounds
- The shorter sidewall
decreases flexing
- The decreased rolling
radius numerically increases gear ratio about 5%
Finally,
some successful Saturn autocrossers have been known to run
225/50R15’s on only the front axle in order to change
the handling balance of the car. If you run this
configuration, keep in mind that wheel spacers are mandatory
to keep the front tires from crashing into important things
like brake lines! The tire is also way too wide for the 6"
factory wheels (although we have seen it done). Due to these
clearance issues, we do not recommend running this
size on the street.
For most
competitors, the choice of tire manufacturer is more often
than not based on what ‘the fast guys are running’. Our
testing experience has shown that our SSC car works best
with 205/50ZR15 Hoosier R3S03 Radials. Since the Hoosiers
are a little ‘wider’ than most other 205’s, we use 5mm thick
H&R wheel spacers to generate adequate tire to strut
clearance. (Past experience with other tire brands has shown
that spacers are not necessary with any other currently
available 205/50ZR15 tire.) Without the spacers, the tire
would eat right through the strut – especially with the
large static camber settings we use. As with any tire,
investment in a good pressure gage and pyrometer will help
you to quickly and accurately determine optimum tire
pressures and alignment settings.
More Power!
Although in
stock trim the Saturn powerplant makes a respectable amount
of horsepower and torque, you can never have enough of
either. It sure is disappointing to watch that 140+ horse
Nissan walk you at the start of the race time and time
again…
In E-Stock,
SSC, and ITA, you really can’t do much with the engine –
legally, anyhow. We have found through dyno testing that a
fresh rebuild with a K+N air filter, Red Line Racing Oil,
and a 2" open exhaust (no muffler) from the cat-back will
net about 130 horsepower at the crank, up 6 hp from the
advertised ‘stock’ rating. It may not seem like much, but
that’s about a 5% power increase. Further testing with
aftermarket spark plugs and plug wires made no difference –
evidently the stock ignition system is pretty robust at
these power levels. Finally, for ITA, SPS offers a great
tri-Y ceramic-coated header (be sure to scrap the cat while
you’re down there).
For those of
you not limited by preparation rules, take heart that in
addition to the modifications listed above, the Saturn
powerplant will respond quite well to basic hot-rodding
techniques. Keep in mind, however, that you should not
expect small block power from the little 1.9l…
1. Compression,
compression, compression. With the Saturn 1994-1997 DOHC,
there are two simple ways to raise the compression ratio:
- Shave the head – taking
off 0.50mm will bump the ratio from 9.5 to about 10.2
- Install the flat faced
intake and exhaust valves from a 1991-1993 DOHC – this
alone will bump the ratio +0.3
2. Get air in, get
air out. A quick list of what has worked for us on our
project car:
- Extrude Honed intake and
exhaust manifolds
- SPS enlarged throttle
body (52mm, up from 50mm)
- SPS powerstack intake
with K+N filter
With all
these modifications and an otherwise stock exhaust system,
our project car runs consistent 15.8’s in the quarter mile
(stock 2’s run about 16.5 seconds). More extensive exhaust
work planned for next year should bring that down into the
mid-15’s, or so we hope.
Transaxle
Trivia
Sorry, but
there are no big secrets here. In both E-Stock and SSC you
can legally change your transaxle fluid - that’s it. We
happen to use Red Line D4, and after one season of abuse -
and without changing the fluid even once - the transaxle
internals looked as good as new (crew chief note: that
included a few too many 8000 RPM downshifts). The transaxle
appears to be bulletproof at these power levels.
The ITA
crowd and street car folks have a few more options. Although
very hard to come by, a limited slip or torque-biasing
differential makes a world of difference. Our project street
car is equipped with a Torsen torque-biasing differential,
and exiting corners on the throttle is no longer a waiting
game (if only it were SSC legal…). Final drive gears are
also ITA legal, and with the incredibly low 0.73:1 fifth
gear ratio you will probably want to ‘super size’ your final
drive, but we do not know of anybody with parts on the shelf
today.
When
shopping for a spare transaxle, be aware that - even though
the internal ratios are different - both the 1-series
transaxle and the 2-series transaxle are mechanically
interchangeable! We know of at least one competitor who
purchased a 1-series transaxle and found out the hard way
that the ratio change is not favorable. I bet he
would have managed to get great fuel economy, though.
Whoa
Power!
Warning - do
not go into this section thinking that you will learn how to
magically shorten your Saturn’s stopping distance! As with
any other automotive application, making changes to your
Saturn’s braking system will not have a significant
impact on stopping distance. If you want to stop in a
shorter distance, go buy stickier tires! However, in order
to compete on a regular basis, changes to your stock braking
system are absolutely necessary to increase fade resistance,
improve pedal feel, and reduce wear.
Rotor heat
storage and dissipation is the number one brake system
concern of any Saturn competitor. Stock Saturn rotors
perform adequately for autocrossing because the brakes are
allowed to cool between each lap, but for road racing the
rotors are not large enough to store the heat generated by
lap after lap of 100 mph stops. Unfortunately, Club Racing
rules prohibit the use of larger rotors, so the heat must be
dealt with in other ways. (Note that ITA drivers can – and
should! – use brake cooling ducts, but the rest of us are
not so lucky.)
The first
line of defense is a quality brake fluid. Several are on the
market, and if you stick with one of the ‘brand names’, you
should be safe. Don’t cut a corner here, or you will find
out going into turn 5 at Road America that your fluid isn’t
up to the task! For street and autocross duty, changing your
fluid once per year is probably overkill, but for the road
racers, bleeding the fluid between every race is mandatory.
In fact, we bleed our fluid between every track session (4
times per race weekend). It might sound unnecessary, but the
first time you forget, it will come back to bite you. Want
to see our battle scars?
The next
upgrade should be brake pads. In this area, autocrossers and
road racers have very different needs, and a great autocross
pad should never be used on a road race car. If your Saturn
sees both autocrossing and road racing duty, you need to
consider separate pads for each type of event.
Autocross-specific brake pads will typically generate peak
output at lower temperatures than road racing pads, and do
not need to get hot before they start to ‘come on’. A good
autocross pad will also have great initial bite and allow
the driver to modulate the pedal throughout the stop. SPS’
Kelate Metallic autocross pads meet all of these criteria,
but like most autocross-specific pads, they will fade
quickly at higher temperatures, so they are not suitable for
road racing applications.
Road racers
will require a pad which operates at higher temperatures
without a loss in performance. During one of our test days,
we used thermal paint to determine our rotor operating
temperatures and found peak temperatures as high as 1100°
F! Because of the high temperatures seen on our SC2, an
insulating liner between the friction material and the
backing plate was deemed to be mandatory for our
application. Expansion grooves were also necessary to
prevent the friction material from cracking as heat built up
– and we found through experimentation that 1 expansion
groove is not enough for a Saturn. We use two grooves
exclusively to prevent premature pad disintegration.
The only
brake pads we have found which meet all of our road racing
requirements are manufactured by PowrPad. Other materials we
have tested in our application have debonded, cracked
excessively, or transferred excessive heat to the brake
fluid. And although the PowrPads have the ceramic liner and
twin expansion grooves, they only last about 2-3 race
weekends before they need replacing. You can’t have
everything, I guess…
The only
other ‘tuning’ you can do to the braking system is to vary
front and rear friction materials to change the braking
balance of the car. We think of it as using the brake pads
as a bias bar. In 1998, we chose to use a slightly more
aggressive rear compound to help the car turn-in under
trailbraking conditions, but in the rain, one could use a
less aggressive rear material keep the back end in line! In
either case, this parameter is best evaluated by each
individual driver.
Finally,
unless your Saturn came equipped with ABS, you are stuck
with rear drum brakes; however, you can easily convert it to
rear disc brakes using factory parts. The rear knuckle and
bearing are the same for the disc and drum cars, so you can
complete the entire job without even having to reset your
alignment. Best of all, SPS has recently assembled a kit
which includes all of the hardware necessary (even
fasteners) to complete the job in your driveway in a few
hour’s time. The serious competitor will not hesitate to
make the switch – and it’s SSC and ITA legal to boot.
Suspension
Science
Before going
any further, please keep in mind that what the chassis
engineer ‘likes’ and what the driver ‘likes’ can be 180°
out of phase with each other. Unlike other vehicle systems,
chassis tuning is as much ‘art’ as it is ‘science’. The only
underlying truism is: if it gets you to the checkered flag
first, it’s right! With that in mind…
We have
found that the Saturn suspension should be attacked as a
system, and that randomly replacing individual components
without some forward thought can actually have a detrimental
effect on chassis dynamics. What we will roll out below are
a series of upgrade ‘stages’, but remember that the first
step toward the improved chassis of any Saturn involves
swapping in some real wheels and tires!
The first
stage involves ‘firming things up’. A strut tower brace,
although illegal in all but CSP, will make an immediate
difference. Keeping the stock springs in place but replacing
the struts with KYB units will raise rebound damping rates
without keeping the springs from doing their job. Adding a
larger rear anti-sway bar (16.5mm diameter) from SPS will
dial out some of the factory understeer, but keep in mind
that if you choose to add a front bar as well, you will
negate part of this effect. These changes will make for a
fun to drive street car with minimal impacts to ride
comfort. For the street, alignment should be kept
reasonable, with no more than -1.25°
camber front and rear, zero front toe, and a hair of toe-in
in the rear.
The next
stage is to upgrade to a high-performance street set-up. H&R
sport lowering springs, when combined with Carrera street
struts, make for a firm, but tolerable, ride. With the
installation of the H&R springs, an SPS 3-way adjustable
16.5mm rear anti-sway bar can now be used to make fine
chassis adjustments (note: we recommend leaving the front
bar stock in this configuration). Adding 10mm to the track
width with spacers makes for wheel clearance and helps to
reduce body roll a small amount. Alignment can now be turned
up a notch, but any more than -2.0°
camber front and rear will wear out street tires in a hurry.
Front toe out should be set to the driver’s preference, and
rear toe should depend on what type of racing you are
setting up for – zero toe for road racing, and <gulp> some
toe out for the autocrossers. Be aware that at this point,
you are close to crossing the line between daily driver and
weekend warrior. At scR motorsports, we utilized these same
components in our 1998 SSC ‘trunk kit’, and found the
handling balance to be ideal for road racing.
Teaser line:
for 1999, we have re-engineered the SSC ‘trunk kit’ with the
assistance of H&R, SPS, and several others. At the time of
this writing, the package has not been voted on by the SCCA
Comp Board, but by the time you read this, something should
be official – one way or the other. Be sure to visit our
website at www.teamscR.com for the latest on the 1999
allowances.
For the ITA
curious, there are coil-over kits available to transform
your suspension package from high-performance street to
full-race. At this stage, springs are best determined by
experimentation and driver preference, but rates are
available to suit any taste. Camber plates, minor geometry
changes, and better bushings are all fair game, but with so
many schools of thought on how to set up a front-wheel drive
race car, we won’t go there. Experiment and find what works
best for you.
What Doesn’t
Work? What Are The Weak Links?
Our
self-generated list of broken parts, lessons learned, and
dollars wasted:
- -Suspension bushings are a
great idea if you can replace them all the way
around. If you replace only some of them, you might
get unwanted understeering or oversteering of the rear
axle.
- -Don’t replace the front
anti-sway bar unless you are prepared to go with a huge
rear bar. -Use springs to control front roll angles
instead.
- -If you lower the car more
than 30mm, be prepared to replace front axles on a regular
basis – the resulting axle angles will eat the CV joints.
- -If you do end up road
racing, buy a whole bunch of rear wheel bearings. Over the
course of 9 races, we went through 5 pair. Front bearings
are a little more robust – 1 set should last 6 races or
so.
- -Spend real money for
quality brake fluid and brake pads. Saturn racers will
curse the day they shortcut this critical area.
- -Don’t spend money for any
Saturn engine components which magically add 15
horsepower. -They don’t exist, and unless you only run on
the street, they’re probably illegal anyway.
Putting It All Together
Now that you
have been saturated with Saturnalia, you are probably
sitting back and saying to yourself, "Self, this sounds like
any other GRM article". Well, you are right…the preparation
and maintenance of the Saturn SC2 is as simple as that for a
GTI, Miata, Civic, or Neon. Contrary to popular belief, the
Saturn does not require special care or feeding, and in most
cases is actually easier to maintain than other popular
marquees.
To sum it
all up, there is no silver bullet which will enable your
Saturn to heroically catapult to the top of the pack, but
when you combine the light weight, agile suspension,
flexible powertrain, and growing aftermarket support for the
Saturn SC2, you might just realize that Saturn provides one
of the most competitive packages to campaign, no matter what
your end goals. Get ready to run "rings" around your
competition!
SIDEBAR 1 -
The Saturn Decoder Ring, Part I
All of the
vehicles in the current Saturn lineup are identified by
specific model names which, at first, seem like a random
string of numbers and letters – SC2, SL1, etc. Here is the
super-secret decoder ring to figure out just what each model
name means (I could get fired for giving this away).
- The first character in
the model name will always be an ‘S’. Maybe it stands for
‘Saturn’, but I don’t know for sure.
- The second character in
the model name identifies the body style: ‘C’ for coupe,
‘W’ for wagon, and ‘L’ for sedan. Hence, you can choose
from the Saturn SC, SW, and
SS SL.
Freudian slip – Saturn SS. Ha! What was I thinking?
- The third character in
the model name essentially indicates the engine and
suspension configuration: ‘1’ for the 8 valve single cam
engine / base suspension and ‘2’ for the 16 valve twin cam
engine / performance suspension. See the next side bar to
decipher these cryptic phrases.
For example,
the Saturn SC2 is a Saturn coupe with the performance
suspension and twin cam engine. An SW1 is a Saturn wagon
with the base suspension and single cam engine. Simple once
you have broken the code, right? What it really boils down
to is that, under the body panels, Saturn only produces two
cars – the 1-series and the 2-series. The rest is just
bodywork – from the underside an SC2 is the same as an SL2,
an SL1 is the same as an SW1, and so forth.
Hopefully my
desk will not be cleared out when I get to work Monday
morning!
SIDEBAR 2 -
The Saturn Decoder Ring, Part II
Most
1991-1997 Saturns share common engines, transmissions,
braking systems, and suspension system components. In order
to quickly spell out what differences do exist
between the 1-series and 2-series cars, we have compiled
this quick-reference guide (as opposed to having quickly
compiled this reference guide).
| |
1-Series
Saturns |
2-Series
Saturns |
|
Engine |
|
|
|
Displacement |
1.9 l, 8
valve SOHC I4 |
1.9 l, 16
valve DOHC I4 |
|
Material |
Aluminum
block and head |
Same |
|
Compression Ratio (:1) |
9.3 |
9.5 |
|
Power |
100 hp @
5000 rpm |
124 hp @
5600 rpm |
|
Torque |
114
ft-lb. @ 2400 rpm |
122
ft-lb. @ 4800 rpm |
|
Redline |
5600 rpm |
6750 rpm |
|
Manual Transmission |
|
|
1st–5th Gear Ratios (:1) |
3.25,
1.81, 1.17, 0.81, 0.61 |
3.25,
2.06, 1.42, 1.03, 0.73 |
|
Final Drive Ratio (:1) |
4.06,
open differential |
Same |
|
Brakes |
|
|
|
Front Brakes |
250mm
vented disc
(ABS optional) |
Same |
|
Rear Brakes |
200mm
drum |
Same, but
251mm disc
with ABS option |
|
Chassis / Suspension |
|
|
Wheelbase |
102.4"
(99.2" for '91-'96 SC’s) |
Same |
|
Front Track |
56.8" |
Same |
|
Rear Track |
56.0" |
Same |
|
Front Suspension |
Independent strut with lateral link and integral
anti-sway bar |
Same, but
with larger front
28.6mm anti-sway bar |
|
Rear Suspension |
Independent tri-link
with strut module |
Same, but
adds rear
15mm anti-sway bar |
|
Steering Ratio (:1) |
18.3,
power assist |
16.3,
variable effort power assist |
|
Wheels |
14" x 5" |
15" x 6" |
(Disclaimer: the figures stated above are specifically
for the 1997 model year. Saturn has progressively
tweaked its vehicles since 1991, but the figures for all
1991-1997 Saturns are pretty darn similar to those
listed above.)
 |